Minefields/Mines

Turbografx · 09-28-09, 08:17 PM

One thing I hope to see have more of a presence in SH5 are mines. Quite a number of u-boats during the war (1/3 in WWI and 10% in WWII) were sunk by mines and yet in all my years of SH, SH3, SH4, I've never once been sunk by a mine. Statistically, one in 10 of my losses should be to mines.

Hopefully it would also cut down on the heavy use of TC by giving us areas where careful attention is required.

What do you think?

Fluffysheap · 09-28-09, 10:03 PM

Well, you have the advantage real captains did not - you know where the minefields are in advance.

It also depends on your patrol area somewhat. If you patrol England's east coast, you'll have more trouble with mines than if you go out to the middle of the Atlantic. (Unless you hit a mine on the way there!)

I've been sunk by mines three times, but then, I play a lot of Type II. Actually, in 1940, I think mines are more trouble than destroyers. If I don't want to hit mines, I have to patrol farther off the coast, which means fewer targets, and more of those are neutrals and warships.

kptn_kaiserhof · 09-28-09, 10:58 PM

hey guys on the topic of mines how cool would it be to have the ability to lay them with your submarine and get a kill credit when a ship hits it

Arclight · 09-29-09, 12:35 AM

Very cool, but you're really fighting the odds on that one.

nattydread · 09-29-09, 01:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Turbografx

Statistically, one in 10 of my losses should be to mines.

Not necessarily true...but I get what you mean. It depends an where and how you operate.

Fluffysheap · 09-29-09, 03:22 AM

Oh, also, mines are a lot more dangerous in GWX than in stock. It's possible to hit a mine in stock but you have to be both careless and unlucky. In GWX there are many more mines and they are placed more dangerously, you didn't say which version you played.

Jimbuna · 09-29-09, 04:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fluffysheap

Oh, also, mines are a lot more dangerous in GWX than in stock. It's possible to hit a mine in stock but you have to be both careless and unlucky. In GWX there are many more mines and they are placed more dangerously, you didn't say which version you played.

We were very lucky to be given a set of Admiralty minefield charts (not available to the public) which enabled us to place the minefields around the UK with a high level of accuracy.

I'd really like to see the ability to lay mines and receive credit for any sinkings in game.

DarkFish · 09-29-09, 09:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Turbografx

One thing I hope to see have more of a presence in SH5 are mines. Quite a number of u-boats during the war (1/3 in WWI and 10% in WWII) were sunk by mines and yet in all my years of SH, SH3, SH4, I've never once been sunk by a mine. Statistically, one in 10 of my losses should be to mines.

Hopefully it would also cut down on the heavy use of TC by giving us areas where careful attention is required.

What do you think?

You can't spot them unless you're on the bridge 24/7 at 32x compression max. So it'd be like you're gently sailing at high TC and suddenly you get "sir, we're taking damage"

Dowly · 09-29-09, 10:01 AM

We need RAF dropping eggs to our harbors too.

Turbografx · 09-29-09, 11:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dowly

We need RAF dropping eggs to our harbors too.

That too could make things interesting as you enter and leave harbor.

Safe-Keeper · 09-29-09, 02:55 PM

Quote:

You can't spot them unless you're on the bridge 24/7 at 32x compression max. So it'd be like you're gently sailing at high TC and suddenly you get "sir, we're taking damage"

Am I missing something? Isn't that the whole idea?

DarkFish · 09-30-09, 07:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Safe-Keeper

Am I missing something? Isn't that the whole idea?

Yeah it is but if you can't somehow detect them or know where the minefields are they're just very annoying. I don't want to suddenly get a death screen if I don't know any reason for it.

09-30-09, 12:09 PM

i too would love an "instant replay" death screen as it were with exterior view camera sort of explaining why im dead.

nothing that lasts too long but just like your last 10 seconds or so of game time being repeated in a way to "show" you why you died

that spin around the boat thing does not help much at all to know what happened and IMHO is something they could have left out

looney · 10-04-09, 12:47 PM

I'd love to see minefields in game.. but I rather get a standard renown number for laying mines then only if an enemy ship hit the mine. Mines where laid not to sink ships (that was only a bonus) but to make ship movement slower, and more costly.

When we get credit for hitting a ship with a mine I think we are trying to lay them in front of a ship and not in a plan for the "Greater" good.

I'd like to command a type 7D and get coordinates where to place my mines and get renown for the accuracy of laying the mines. For instance get 2 sectors where to lay the mines... 1 more difficult (in front of a harbour) -> higher difficulty thus more renown/mine.. 2nd easy place to lay thus less renown/mine.

prowler3 · 10-10-09, 09:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fluffysheap

Oh, also, mines are a lot more dangerous in GWX than in stock. It's possible to hit a mine in stock but you have to be both careless and unlucky. In GWX there are many more mines and they are placed more dangerously, you didn't say which version you played.

I have personally lost 4 GWX campaigns to mines...all around the British Isles. The German spies have had a hard time getting accurate info??

09-28-09, 08:17 PM	#1
Turbografx Old Stormalong Join Date: Dec 2007 Location: The Gret Stet of Loosiana Posts: 232 Downloads: 104 Uploads: 0	Minefields/Mines One thing I hope to see have more of a presence in SH5 are mines. Quite a number of u-boats during the war (1/3 in WWI and 10% in WWII) were sunk by mines and yet in all my years of SH, SH3, SH4, I've never once been sunk by a mine. Statistically, one in 10 of my losses should be to mines. Hopefully it would also cut down on the heavy use of TC by giving us areas where careful attention is required. What do you think?

09-29-09, 12:35 AM	#4
Arclight Navy Seal Join Date: Jun 2008 Location: Land of windmills, tulips, wooden shoes and cheese. Lots of cheese. Posts: 8,467 Downloads: 53 Uploads: 10	Very cool, but you're really fighting the odds on that one. __________________ Contritium praecedit superbia.

09-28-09, 10:03 PM	#2
Fluffysheap Bosun Join Date: Jan 2009 Posts: 63 Downloads: 8 Uploads: 0	Well, you have the advantage real captains did not - you know where the minefields are in advance. It also depends on your patrol area somewhat. If you patrol England's east coast, you'll have more trouble with mines than if you go out to the middle of the Atlantic. (Unless you hit a mine on the way there!) I've been sunk by mines three times, but then, I play a lot of Type II. Actually, in 1940, I think mines are more trouble than destroyers. If I don't want to hit mines, I have to patrol farther off the coast, which means fewer targets, and more of those are neutrals and warships.

09-28-09, 10:58 PM	#3
kptn_kaiserhof XO Join Date: Aug 2005 Posts: 418 Downloads: 42 Uploads: 0	hey guys on the topic of mines how cool would it be to have the ability to lay them with your submarine and get a kill credit when a ship hits it

09-29-09, 03:22 AM	#6
Fluffysheap Bosun Join Date: Jan 2009 Posts: 63 Downloads: 8 Uploads: 0	Oh, also, mines are a lot more dangerous in GWX than in stock. It's possible to hit a mine in stock but you have to be both careless and unlucky. In GWX there are many more mines and they are placed more dangerously, you didn't say which version you played.

09-29-09, 10:01 AM	#9
Dowly Lucky Jack Join Date: Apr 2005 Location: Finland Posts: 25,005 Downloads: 32 Uploads: 0	We need RAF dropping eggs to our harbors too.

09-30-09, 12:09 PM	#13
Webster Stowaway Posts: n/a Downloads: Uploads:	i too would love an "instant replay" death screen as it were with exterior view camera sort of explaining why im dead. nothing that lasts too long but just like your last 10 seconds or so of game time being repeated in a way to "show" you why you died that spin around the boat thing does not help much at all to know what happened and IMHO is something they could have left out

10-04-09, 12:47 PM	#14
looney Commodore Join Date: May 2007 Location: Sneek, The Netherlands Posts: 635 Downloads: 43 Uploads: 0	I'd love to see minefields in game.. but I rather get a standard renown number for laying mines then only if an enemy ship hit the mine. Mines where laid not to sink ships (that was only a bonus) but to make ship movement slower, and more costly. When we get credit for hitting a ship with a mine I think we are trying to lay them in front of a ship and not in a plan for the "Greater" good. I'd like to command a type 7D and get coordinates where to place my mines and get renown for the accuracy of laying the mines. For instance get 2 sectors where to lay the mines... 1 more difficult (in front of a harbour) -> higher difficulty thus more renown/mine.. 2nd easy place to lay thus less renown/mine.