If you want statistics and excissve logging of thes,e ewvrything, then Hunte rclassic is your choice, and by a far lead so.
By statistics I once was amongst the 300 "best" players worldwide. They then changed the system, and I had a break form having overplayed it, and so that went down.
https://thehunter.fandom.com/de/wiki/TheHunter_Wikia
Classic still does some thignbs better than COTA, amognst them huntign with the air rifle, becasue here the mils in the scope really mean something, must be manually adjusted to compensate for bullet drop. Hunting rabbits with it in Australia really is a different game.
There is a reason why Classic just refuses to die and is still popular both with new players and old veterans. 14 years, counting! So many memories. An absolute highlight in my gaming "career", though it never was perfect, and still is not, and I have had my quarrels with it and with the devs. But weighing in all pros and cos, and by the end of the day: an absolute highlight in my gamer's life, and I have lots of love for it.