Quote:
Originally Posted by Cybermat47
All the destroyers were attacking another U-boat on the other side of the convoy.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sailor Steve
Why is that unrealistic? u-boats didn't usually get surprised by destroyers, but it did happen. One of the main points about the book and the movie seems to be that anything and everything goes wrong, from start to finish.
|
Nonsens.
I remember ther was a complete silence before the atack. And then suddenly they saw destroyer near by. WTF? They didnt heard him comming ? How come ? Was sonar man sleeping ?
No. It was just made to create drama. So that scene is not realistic.
And one thing. I dont remember exactly but I think they saw the convoy through binoculars and went full speed ahead emerged or something like that, I cant remember now, but there was something I thought it was not realistic or stupid risky.
Nevertheless I ignore it, and it is still one of my top favorite movies. Thats unquestionable.